Picking the Standings: AL Central
The AL Central has proved itself to be among baseball’s best divisions, and it might be the best in the entire game. The Cleveland Indians may be the most underrated 96-win team of all time, while the Detroit Tigers swung a super-steal, er, deal, and became an offensive powerhouse. The Chicago White Sox, instead of trying to rebuild, decided to take a gamble and build up their lineup. The Kansas City Royals continue to be the Kansas City Royals, and the Minnesota Twins entered a full-scale rebuilding mode by dealing their best player. Here’s how they’ll finish (with their projected 2008 records in parentheses):
1. Cleveland Indians (94-6
- The Indians had a tremendous 2007 after a tremendous disappointment in 2006, but they still had a 3-1 lead in the ALCS and couldn’t get it done. The 2008 Cleveland Indians will look to take the next step. They didn’t do anything besides change the name of their stadium over the offseason, acquiring a Japanese reliever as their “big” move. This was because their roster is already stacked. C.C. Sabathia and Fausto Carmona are Cleveland’s pocket aces, and Jake Westbrook isn’t bad either. Travis Hafner is set to bounce back, Grady Sizemore is a stud, and catcher Victor Martinez is the most underrated position player in baseball. Ryan Garko and Franklin Gutierrez will continue their development. Look for the Indians to cruise into the playoffs for the second consecutive season.
2. Detroit Tigers (90-72) - The Tigers made a huge improvement to their lineup and a smaller yet still significant improvement to their rotation by acquiring Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis from the Florida Marlins for six prospects, including projected stars Andrew Miller and Cameron Maybin. Now Detroit’s lineup looks scary good. After subsequent acquisitions of Edgar Renteria and Jacque Jones, the Tigers now sport the MLB’s best starting nine. It’s the pitching that must be questioned. Besides Justin Verlander, everyone is a question mark. D-Train and Jeremy Bonderman both had ERAs over five in 2007, and Nate Robertson is adequate. No one knows what Kenny Rogers will do. I think this team will struggle early, and then pick it up late, but it won’t be enough to make the playoffs. At least, not this year.
3. Chicago White Sox (82-80) - Ultra-agressive GM Kenny Williams truly believes that last year’s last place finish was a fluke, and he went out and proved it by significantly improving his team this winter. Nick Swisher joins mashers Jim Thome and Jermaine Dye in a very solid and underrated lineup. New young outfielder Carlos Quentin could still become a star. Orlando Cabrera and A.J. Piersynski can still hit. Youngster Josh Fields could make dramatic improvements, if he gets a starting job. However, the problem with the Pale Hose is that their pitching is still suspect. Jose Contreras is not the same as he was in 2005. Neither are Mark Beuhrle or Javier Vasquez. Jon Garland was traded for Cabrera. Chicago’s AL team still needs one or two more big pieces to get up to the range of the division heavyweights.
4. Minnesota Twins (75-87) - The Twinkies made a huge move after much interal struggle, trading Johan Santana to the Mets for four underwhelming prospects. The best one of those, teenage pitcher Deolis Guerra, won’t be ready for the majors until 2010. Centerfielder (and possible track star) Carlos Gomez will get the start, but pitchers Phil Humber and Kevin Mulvey will have to audition. The Twins did do something right, however, when they locked up young studs Justin Morneau and Michael Cuddyer long-term. The Twins will be depending on the left arm of young superstar Francisco Liriano to anchor their pitching staff, but that might be a problem considering the last time Liriano pitched was in 2006. The Twins will struggle in 2008, that’s for sure. But…
5. Kansas City Royals (69-93) - …they won’t be quite as bad as the floundering Royals, who haven’t won anything in what seems like ages. The pitching staff might be the best part about the team, headlined by the underrated and overpaid Gil Meche and young stud Brian Bannister. But their number 3 is a busted prospect (athough his ERA was better than Chien-Ming Wang’s in 2007). The lineup is even worse, with such superstars as Mark Grudzielanek and Ross Gload. Alex Gordon and Mark Teahen have shown promise, but the rest of the lineup is a crapshoot (see Jose Guillen). The bullpen is pretty bad as well, sporting Joakim Soria as the closer. Over the past couple of years, the front office has shown a willingness to spend a little, giving big contracts to Meche and Guillen, but the payroll is among the last in the league. The Royals will be, as well.
I see the Indians making the playoffs as the three seed, with the Tigers barely missing the playoffs to the much-improved Mariners. The Twins are entering rebuilding, while the White Sox refuse to. And, as has been previously mentioned, the Royals are still the Royals. The AL Central figures to be pretty dull in 2008, but there’s hope for excitement in the future as the Tigers mature and the Twins rebuild.